Kirtland AFB Meeting - November 14, 2007

November 15th, 2007

Col. Suminsby, the new Kirtland AFB Base Commander, met with the public to share Kirtland’s plans to release 400 acres of Withdrawal land to the public. While this appeared to be a friendly gesture, the discussions became heated once the Question & Answer session began.

400 acres of land have been identified for potential release to the USFS, not really the public. We, the public, will have a long wait before we are ever allowed to set foot (or bicycle tire) on the land. A map showing this 400 acres is available at this link. A formal Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) is planned for this area. The previous EIS conducted for the fence is invalid because the purpose of the EIS is different.  Once/if the EIS is approved, the USFS receives the land and will go through their own environmental studies…on the SAME land. There will not be a joint attempt to combine these efforts with the AFB, based upon a statement from Nancy Rose of the USFS. This is all part of the NEPA process. Bureaucracy is alive and thriving.

How can we expedite the process? Write letters to your Congressional representatives. Congresswoman Wilson has been supportive of Otero Canyon in the past. She especially needs to know that this is not moving in the positive direction she intended.

Contact information is here. Keep in mind that handwritten letters carry much more weight than email. In most cases, you will receive a written response. In addition, it’s best to mail letters to local addresses rather than DC for a quicker response.

Press Release - November 6, 2007
Public Meeting Notice

November 6th, 2007

MEDIA ADVISORY

UNITED STATES AIR FORCE

Office of Public Affairs, 377th Air Base Wing, 2000 Wyoming Blvd. SE, Ste. A-1
Kirtland Air Force Base, New Mexico 87117-5606, (505) 846-5991, DSN 246-5991

Nov 6, 2007
Release #07-24

Public Meeting to discuss potential land transfer

KIRTLAND AIR FORCE BASE, N.M. – Kirtland AFB will be holding a public meeting on Wednesday, Nov. 14 to discuss the potential return of 400 acres on Kirtland’s eastern boundary to the US Forest Service. The meeting will be held at the Manzano High School auditorium and will start at 6 p.m. Members of the public are welcome and encouraged to attend.

Col. Robert Suminsby Jr., Commander of the 377th Air Base Wing, will be giving a briefing on the background of the land, commonly referred to as “Otero Canyon,” as well as the proposed land transfer options that Kirtland has decided to pursue in cooperation with the US Forest Service. A question and answer session will immediately follow the briefing to address any concerns or issues the public may have.

“Kirtland is committed to preserving public access to the existing trail system within Otero Canyon, and has decided to pursue a solution that can hopefully accommodate the desires of the majority of outdoor enthusiasts who have enjoyed this area for years,” said Colonel Suminsby.

Manzano High School is located at 12200 Lomas Blvd. People interested in attending the public meeting should park in the school parking lot and enter through the auditorium on the North end of the school.

-30-

EDITOR’S NOTE: For further information, or to cover the event, please contact the 377th Air Base Wing Public Affairs office at 846-5991.

Press Release - June 19, 2007 - Air Force will NOT build Otero Canyon fence

June 19th, 2007

Wilson Says Air Force will drop bid to build fence in Otero Canyon

Washington D.C. - Congresswoman Heather Wilson announced today that the United States Air Force has decided not to build a fence in the popular Otero Canyon in the Manzano Mountains east of Albuquerque. The area is popular with hikers, bikers, and nature lovers, who feared that a fence would close off access to miles of trails people have enjoyed for years. Wilson took up the issue early on and fought to keep Kirtland Air Force Base officials from fencing the area off to users other than where required for safety.

Wilson says the Air Force has decided that some of the area on the northeast boundary of Kirtland’s range area is no longer required to support Kirtland’s mission. The Air Force will now initiate a National Environment Policy Act (NEPA) process to assess the land and its potential uses.
“New Mexicans have used this area to hike and bike for many years,” says Wilson. “A fence would not have helped security. Over the last few years, I’ve worked with dozens of people who love the recreation opportunities available on this land. Today, we can declare victory. I am thankful to the Air Force for listening to reasonable people.”

As the issue first percolated, Wilson hiked a stretch of Otero Canyon to learn more about concerns surrounding access to those trails. Wilson was the first high-ranking public official in 2003 to publicly support efforts to preserve access to the trails for nature enthusiasts who hike and bike in the area.

In June 2003, Wilson asked officials at Kirtland Air Force Base to take a balanced approach based on Otero Canyon’s unique aspects, as well as the Base’s needs. At Wilson’s request, the public comment period at the time was then extended.

“I picked a great time to hike the Otero Trails,” said a muddied Wilson at the time after her hike in a rain-soaked Otero Canyon. “After days of rain, a soggy trail can be a challenge. I can see how much fun it is to hike or bike here, so I fully understand why people are so passionate about preserving access to this beautiful part of the Manzanos.”
“As always, the cycling community is very appreciative of Congresswoman Heather Wilson’s direct involvement in the Otero Canyon issue,” said Matt Turgeon, a local mountain biker and member of Friends of Otero (FOOMTB.org). FOOMTB is a not-for-profit, trail advocacy group that opposes closing any part of the Otero Trail System.

“From the very beginning, Heather has been involved in the fight to save Otero Canyon and she took the lead in finding this new solution,” said Turgeon. “The chasm between KAFB and the public was huge at the onset, but with Heather’s involvement the public appears to be able to regain their land back. This is not only great for Tijeras and Albuquerque, but the entire state. The Crown Jewel of New Mexico’s cycling trails will soon be re-opened to the public.”

Base officials had proposed building a fence along part of Kirtland’s eastern boundary in the Manzanita Mountains. The area, known as Otero Canyon, is heavily used by nature enthusiasts who hike and bike in the area. The Canyon has also been featured in outdoor magazines that have touted its trails as some of the best in the nation.
In multiple meetings in Washington and New Mexico over the years, Wilson has made the point to Air Force officials that the fence would not improve security because it was easily circumvented and would be difficult to patrol. In addition, she pointed out to the Air Force that the five mile distance from the eastern border to the populated part of the base is greater protection than a fence. She also urged the base to identify safety hazards and clearly post the dangers.
Wilson has consistently worked to keep Kirtland Air Force Base strong, anticipating rounds of Base Realignment and Closure Commission. She has also worked to preserve New Mexico’s natural beauty, most notably through the federal purchase of the Baca Ranch in northern New Mexico and the Tres Pistolas nature area in the East Mountains, and the preservation of the Ojito Wilderness in Central New Mexico and the Valle Vidal in Northern New Mexico.

“Heather Wilson has credibility with the Air Force and used it to help the community,” said Turgeon. “She was uniquely positioned to get this fixed. Common sense prevailed because of her persistence and credibility.”

Link to Story Here

Press Release - October 23, 2006

October 23rd, 2006

Download the MS Word version of this press release.


Congresswoman Heather Wilson and her staff met with the Department of Defense Assistant Secretary for Installations, Environment and Logistics on June 20 and July 17, 2006 to discuss the continuing controversy surrounding Otero Canyon in Albuquerque, New Mexico.

Otero Canyon is a popular hiking, biking, equestrian and bird watching area on the east side of the Sandia Mountains. This area is part of a ‘military withdrawal’ that was leased by Kirtland Air Force Base (KAFB), but not blocked from public use for 50 years. Beginning in 2002, KAFB proposed building a fence that would prohibit access to the popular Otero Canyon trail system. A local advocacy group, Friends of Otero Canyon, submitted an alternative proposal to KAFB that would meet their security needs and also allow continued public access to this area. Many people believe that this alternative location would be less costly to build and maintain and would follow existing fence, road and terrain. KAFB rejected this alternative proposal and secured funding under a proposal to ‘rebuild’ an existing fence line. In reality, there had never been an existing fence at their proposed location. As a result, funding was withdrawn and plans for the fence were put on hold. KAFB instead installed signs at the perimeter of the withdrawal land to prevent trail users from unknowingly entering the area.

The ‘military withdrawal’ land is currently being leased by two entities: the Department of Defense (DOD) and the Department of Energy (DOE). KAFB’s (DOD) primary arguments for proposing the fence were to 1) ‘protect’ the public from unexploded ordinance (UXO) in the Otero Canyon area, and 2) provide a continuous fence line along the withdrawal perimeter to preserve KAFB security.

The Congresswoman, who has pursued this issue intimately for the past three years, responded to the Friends of Otero in a letter that outlines her meetings with the Assistant Secretary regarding the Otero Canyon trail system issues. Following are key points from her discussion:

• “DOE objects to having a fence on their portion of the eastern boundary, making the DOD area fence of questionable utility.” This means that, if the fence project continues as proposed, only part of the boundary would be fenced. The rest would remain completely open.

• “The Army Corps of Engineers Albuquerque District recently completed a preliminary UXO study of the 2,700 acres in question. The study consisted of a limited walk over, a records search, and aerial imagery. Their preliminary findings suggest that the amount of dangerous UXO in the areas is limited. The Army Corps of Engineers Omaha District is in the process of reviewing the data from the study and will issue a more exhaustive report in the near future.”

• “…the forthcoming DOD/KAFB proposal for securing the eastern boundary of the KAFB will be different enough from the original proposal to require a completely new EA, comment period, and finding of no significant impact.”

Due to the controversy of this proposed fence and both the public and political opposition to its proposed location, the decision regarding fencing Otero Canyon now rests at the national level in the hands of the Secretary of the Air Force. Congresswoman Wilson will meet with the Assistant Secretary again in September to follow up on progress toward a final decision on Otero Canyon. The Congresswoman continues to advocate moving any proposed fence line as far west as safely possible to maximize access to the trail system.

Hike with Congresswoman Heather Wilson

April 6th, 2004


On Tuesday, April 6th, Friends of Otero joined New Mexico Congresswoman Heather Wilson in a hike in the Otero Canyon area.

UPDATE: We have a new press release dated 4/8/04. Download the MS Word Version or the PDF Version.



News Coverage:

MV Telegraph - Rep. Wilson Sees Hope for Otero

Editorial: Heather Wilson Went Extra Mile

ABQ Trib: Wilson Takes a Hike on Trails in Otero


-Friends of Otero

P.S. We have a new map available for viewing.

Governor Richardson Lends His Support

March 3rd, 2004

Governor Bill Richardson has voiced support for keeping the trails of Otero Canyon open for public use. Richardson, in a letter addressed to Kirtland Air Force Base Commander Colonel Henry Andrews, stated that he was “hopeful that you can find some way of moving the proposed eastern perimeter fence so that it would lie between the existing trails and the Base.” The Governor continued that “it is clear that the residents of the Albuquerque area, as well as tourists, have used and enjoyed those trails for decades” and that “it is apparent that a sensible compromise is available on this issue.” He concluded his letter by offering the assistance of his office to help keep this trail system open and accessible to the public.



Governor Richardson now joins Senator Jeff Bingaman, Congressman Tom Udall, Congresswoman Heather Wilson, the Albuquerque City Council, the Bernalillo County Commission, the City of Albuquerque Open Space Division and the Village of Tijeras as an opponent to Kirtland Air Force Base’s proposed fencing of the Otero Canyon Trail System.



While Governor Richardson’s suggestion of moving the perimeter fence does not formally endorse the Friends of Otero Canyon alternative proposal, it acknowledges that viable alternatives exist that would allow the Base to secure its Eastern border and yet still keep the current network of recreational trails open for public use. The Governor’s acknowledgment of Otero Canyon as a tourist destination underscores the importance of this destination to the state economy. The offer of assistance from the Governor’s office and his suggestion that it may be appropriate to bring in an independent party to assess Otero Canyon issues demonstrates Richardson’s willingness to work with the Base and the people of New Mexico to insure that good decisions are made regarding this popular recreational area.



Click here for the full Friends of Otero Press Release



Click here for the Governor’s letter

Responses to Colonel Andrews

February 16th, 2004

Base Commander Colonel Henry Andrews issues statement on Otero Canyon
Friends of Otero Members Sandy Knox and Hugh Martin Respond
Friends of Otero Member Jeni Turgeon reponds
Friends of Otero Member John Red-Horse responds
Our friends Erik Peterson and William Wiley Jr. respond in the ABQ Journal
Friends of Otero Member Matt Turgeon responds
Friends of Otero Member Craig Jensen responds

That’s all for now. Stay tuned…
Friends of Otero

Section of Otero Canyon Trails Closed

November 17th, 2003

For Immediate Release: November 17, 2003



SECTION OF OTERO CANYON TRAILS CLOSED



Mountain bikers in the Otero Canyon area, west of Albuquerque, discovered a Kirtland Air Force Base trail closure sign on the morning of November 10, 2003. The sign states, “Danger: Live Weapons Firing Ranges. Do not enter without permission of the installation commander. Violators will be prosecuted.” This sign, erected at the beginning of a trail built within the last 5 years with US Forest Service knowledge, is located at the intersection of the trail and Forest Road 530.


This trail closure has effectively closed the door on the public’s alternative fence proposal in whole despite its endorsement by Congresswoman Heather Wilson, Congressman Tom Udall, Senator Jeff Bingaman, Bernalillo County, The City of Albuquerque, The Village of Tijeras, and over 1800 individuals who have signed the Friends of Otero online petition. This marks the first response from KAFB since the Public Meeting on June 23rd and the closure of the public comment period on July 16th. Based on this response, Friends of Otero is questioning the base’s willingness to work with the public on this issue that has proven to be of great interest to residents of and tourists to New Mexico.


KAFB claims that this portion of land is located in the remote reaches of their M-60 Firing Range. Previously KAFB had claimed a need for closure of this land due to Homeland Security issues, and more recently Unexploded Ordnance (UXO). However, KAFB had not addressed any safety precautions with recreationists in Otero Canyon up until the June 23rd, 2003 Public Hearing in which nearly 600 Otero Canyon supporters attended. KAFB had worked with the public in the early 1990’s and subsequently dropped any attempts to close off this land at that time. The previous attempts by KAFB did not address the newfound safety concerns stemming from the M-60 Firing Range.


This section of trail is nationally recognized and a valued part of the Otero Canyon Trail System. Tourist visits to this trail network contribute to the community of Tijeras, NM and its closure could impact the village’s economy. The trail leads to a popular view at the former US Forest Service fire tower, which has been in existence since the 1930’s and is considered the crown jewel of the Otero Canyon Trail System. Access to the fire tower is now prohibited because of this action by KAFB.


If you would like to share your opinion on this issue, you can contact the Kirtland AFB Commander, Colonel Henry Andrews, directly at:




KAFB Commander

Col. Henry L. Andrews, Jr.

377th Air Base Wing Commander

2000 Wyoming Blvd. SE STE D-2

Kirtland AFB, NM 87117-5606


A full PDF version of the press release, including a photo of the sign, can be found here.